Teresa Palmer as Diana Bishop holding a book in A Discovery of Witches
(Sky One)

A definite ranking of all the books in the All Souls series just in time for fall

Brat summer is over, time for for All Souls autumn!

If one of your favorite ways to spend some time during autumn is bundling up with a book that simply feels like October was locked into its pages—which is, admittedly, how my usual evening looks like—then the All Souls Series by American author Deborah Harkness might be the perfect choice for you.

Recommended Videos

This currently five-book series really has everything urban fantasy readers long for. Centuries-old vampires, powerful witches, lost books, and whirlwind romances that defy all rules of society.

Matthew Goode as Matthew Clairmont and Teresa Palmer as Diana Bishop stand in the Bodleian Library in A Discovery of Witches
The first three books in the series were adapted by Sky One into a show called A Discovery of Witches, which aired from 2018 to 2022, with Matthew Goode and Teresa Palmer as the main characters, Matthew de Clairmont and Diana Bishop (Sky One)

So here’s a ranking of all the books in the All Souls Series, to help you understand what you might be getting into—and with as little spoilers as possible, promise!

5. The Black Bird Oracle

The Black Bird Oracle is the latest novel in the series, published as recently as July 2024, and it returns to Matthew and Diana, the main characters of the first trilogy, after a book-long intermission. It’s not a terrible book by any means—the whole series is very enjoyable, after all—but something had to be in the last place of this ranking and I simply didn’t have enough time to grow fond of The Black Bird Oracle as I did with the other installments in this series. But it does its job of re-introducing us to all the characters we have come to know and love and setting up what might come next in their extraordinary lives.

4. Time’s Convert

Time’s Convert, the fourth book overall, came out in 2018 and shifts its focus from Matthew and Diana after the conclusion of their story and brings us back to the American Revolution. That’s when Matthew meets a young doctor who is eventually going to become his vampire son, Marcus. And in the present day, Marcus and his beloved Phoebe are getting ready for her transformation into a vampire. And sure, this book does not revolve around Matthew and Diana but I am Marcus’s number one fangirl and I loved reading about his backstory as well as seeing his romance with Phoebe unfold.

Matthew Goode as Matthew Clairmont and Edward Bluemel as Marcus Whitmore walk down a flight of stairs in A Discovery of Witches
Marcus was portrayed in the show by none other than Edward “Lord Guildford Dudley” Bluemel (Sky One)

3. Shadow of Night

Shadow of Night is the second installment of the original All Souls Trilogy, which came out in 2012. Now, let it be known that the third and second places on this list are incredibly close—because sure, the second installment of any trilogy is usually the more lackluster one since it acts as a bridge between the beginning and the grand finale, but this one takes place in a version of Elizabethan London filled with witches’ covens and vampire in the service of the crown, so it’s truly a fascinating read. And even though you shouldn’t judge a book by it, it has to be said that this book has the best cover of them all, at least in the edition I own.

Teresa Palmer as Diana Bishop and Matthew Goode as Matthew Clairmont walk together in A Discovery of Witches
Magical Elizabethan London my beloved (Sky One)

2. The Book of Life

Published in 2014, The Book of Life is the final installment of the series’ first trilogy. It brings the story of Matthew and Diana and all their loved ones to a grand, sweeping finale where both their character arcs come to full completion—battling the demons of their pasts, truly stepping into their power, and eventually sticking it to the old order that had ruled the lives of creatures for centuries. All while welcoming some unexpected but much-beloved additions to their family. We love to see a final book in a trilogy that brings all its storylines to a satisfying ending, solving mysteries and riddles that had been left hanging since the very beginning and delivering their characters to a much-deserved happy ending.

1. A Discovery of Witches

It might be cliché, but my favorite one of them all remains the very first book of the series, which started it all back in 2011. With a hauntingly beautiful atmosphere that goes from old libraries at Oxford to French chateaus, the story of the beginning of the romance between Matthew and Diana will always remain close to my heart. Besides, there are few things I love more when it comes to fantasy than slowly uncovering how the world works and what rules govern it, and this book has more than its fair share of it.


The Mary Sue is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Benedetta Geddo
Benedetta Geddo
Benedetta (she/her) lives in Italy and has been writing about pop culture and entertainment since 2015. She has considered being in fandom a defining character trait since she was in middle school and wasn't old enough to read the fanfiction she was definitely reading and loves dragons, complex magic systems, unhinged female characters, tragic villains and good queer representation. You’ll find her covering everything genre fiction, especially if it’s fantasy-adjacent and even more especially if it’s about ASOIAF. In this Bangtan Sonyeondan sh*t for life.