‘Floating island of garbage’: Donald Trump’s Madison Square Garden rally isn’t beating the ‘Nazi party’ allegations

Calling another country a “floating island of garbage” is definitely going to win undecided voters. At least, that’s probably what comedian Tony Hinchcliffe thought when he spoke on stage for a Trump event in Madison Square Garden.

Recommended Videos

Tony started off the joke, saying, “I don’t know if you guys know this, but there is literally a floating island of garbage in the ocean right now.” Was it going to be a terrible refugee joke given Trump’s record of slandering immigrants? It’s not just a hit at immigrants—Tony directly referred to Puerto Rico as the “floating island of garbage.”

Don’t wait for the punchline, because there’s none. The butt of this awful joke is Puerto Rico. It seems that the crowd found the punchline because they started laughing at Tony’s joke. That wasn’t the last of those jokes—Tony wasn’t done with his horrendous set. He joked about being “welcoming” to migrants while making a shoo gesture. He stereotyped Latin Americans as irresponsibly promiscuous, stating that they “loved making babies.” It’s an odd complaint to make, given that Tony’s candidate is pro-birth.

If you laugh, you’re probably racist

Tony complained about having to be politically correct in his set, and it’s understandable why. He gives out a joke, and it’s just blatant, no-context racism. If racism disappeared, perhaps his career would, too. Former secretary of state Hillary Clinton likened Trump’s Madison Square Garden event as a “Nazi party.” It’s as if Tony’s jokes proved Hillary’s description right. For the MAGA crowd and Tony Hinchcliffe, racism is just a laughing matter.

Even more shocking are people defending Tony’s comments. One on Twitter wrote, “He said Puerto Rico, not Puerto Ricans. Nothing he said about Puerto Rico is wrong. It’s why the 4% moved to PA.” It may not be directed towards Puerto Ricans, but it’s a hit to the land of their origin. A nation is made of its people—including its diaspora. When Tony makes comments like that, it includes the people who still remain in Puerto Rico.


The Mary Sue is supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn a small affiliate commission. Learn more about our Affiliate Policy
Author
Image of Vanessa Esguerra
Vanessa Esguerra
Vanessa Esguerra (She/They) has been a Contributing Writer for The Mary Sue since 2023. After graduating with a Bachelor of Arts in Political Economy, she (happily) rejected law school in 2021 and has been a full-time content writer since. Vanessa is currently taking her Master's degree in Japanese Studies in hopes of deepening her understanding of the country's media culture in relation to pop culture, women, and queer people like herself. She speaks three languages but still manages to get lost in the subways of Tokyo with her clunky Japanese. Fueled by iced coffee brewed from local cafés in Metro Manila, she also regularly covers anime and video games while queuing for her next match in League of Legends.