Yesterday Hollaback, a nonprofit advocating to end street harassment, published a recording of the 100-plus unwanted comments received by actress Shoshanna Roberts during a ten-hour span. The video quickly went viral, receiving over a million views and 27,000 comments in less than a day, as well as its fair share of criticism–Bad Feminist author Roxanne Gay had some reservations. Unfortunately, scum-of-the-Earth asshats did as well.
Not long after the recording was posted yesterday, Hollaback was forced to tweet some sadly unsurprising news:
The subject of our PSA is starting to get rape threats on the comments. Can you help by reporting them? http://t.co/NMYCFd9YOm
— Hollaback! (@iHollaback) October 28, 2014
According to AMNY, Hollaback is doing its best to handle online threats posted in response to the video faster than is typically seen on Youtube or Twitter. Despite the nonprofit’s moderation, however (and in an example of the persistence and prevalence of online harassers), the comments posted in response to the video are still a prime example of why we need feminism. Jezebel chose this particularly disgusting comment as an example:
Harassment is defined as unwanted behavior. This woman said NOTHING so how could the guys know that they were harassing her? Fuck this bitch and her campaign to get money to stop men from simply talking to her in public” and “VERBAL HARASSMENT ? WHAT !? This woman should feel good about all these compliments she received. Yeah some guys were acting all weird and creepy but NOBODY TOUCHED HER. Fucking feminists, women these days threat compliments as sexual harassment ?
That pea-brain actually pinpoints a misconception that is really frustrating to me personally as a woman living in New York–although only a relatively small percentage of the harassment Roberts received (that’s a “small percentage” out of over 100, remember) might sound aggressive out of context, even a comment that’s not overtly hostile still isn’t a compliment. “Have a nice day, beautiful” rarely means just that, and all comments doled out by street harassers are aggressive contextually. It’s meaningful to remind victims of harassment that they’re not frigid, ungrateful, or a bitch if, as a man in the video puts it, “someone acknowledging you for being beautiful” feels like a violation and not a compliment.
That being said, there’s no denying that Hollaback’s video only shows street harassment through a problematically narrow lens. Roxane Gay put it better than I could (obviously):
But the racial politics of the video are fucked up. Like, she didn’t walk through any white neighborhoods? — Roxane Gayrten (@rgay) October 29, 2014
I would have made that video like 5 minutes long. I would have taken 6 or 7 women, across race and body types.
— Roxane Gayrten (@rgay) October 29, 2014
With only one, very specific woman, it gives the impression that a singular type of woman is harassed. — Roxane Gayrten (@rgay) October 29, 2014
I think really bad politics were used to make a very necessary, important point.
— Roxane Gayrten (@rgay) October 29, 2014
It’s difficult and uncomfortable to admit that we have to talk about race/class/gender/sexuality/ability/etc, all at once. I get it. — Roxane Gayrten (@rgay) October 29, 2014
- YouTuber Who Sexually Harasses Women Dropped By His Network Amidst Further Allegations of Sexual Harassment
- The Daily Show‘s Jessica Williams Continues Her Beautiful Assault On Catcalling
- Kansas City, Missouri May Soon Outlaw Catcalling; Texas Lifts Proposed Ban on Upskirt Photos
Are you following The Mary Sue on Twitter, Facebook, Tumblr, Pinterest, & Google +?
Published: Oct 29, 2014 03:40 pm